Building a role profile from interviews: responsibilities, decisions and criteria beyond a list of traits
How to build a role profile by interviewing managers and employees: define its purpose, outcomes, decisions, working relationships, constraints and criteria. Includes a template.
The profile explains the work itself
A list such as “responsible, sociable and resilient under pressure” tells candidates and managers little about the actual work. A profile becomes useful when it shows the outcome needed, the conditions in which it is produced and the decisions the person can make independently.
An interview with a single manager may reflect what they want the role to be, while an employee may describe current habits. Compare several perspectives and flag disagreements. Leave out sensitive or discriminatory requirements and have qualified professionals check which rules apply.
Build the profile around accountability and context
Define the purpose and outcomes
Ask the interviewee to finish the sentence “This role exists to…” Then identify a few recurring outcomes, who needs them and what makes each one complete. Define the outcome in terms of what the work achieves. “Secures an agreed decision with a named owner” says more than “runs meetings.”
Explore typical work situations
Ask about a recent routine task, a difficult case and a mistake a new starter made. For each, identify the inputs, decision, people involved and constraints. This shows how the work happens and helps you distinguish essential skills from those needed only in exceptional circumstances.
Define decision authority and working relationships
State what the person decides independently, what needs approval and where to escalate risks. Include the main working relationships and what each side expects. If interviewees identify different owners, flag it for management to resolve and make the disagreement visible.
Separate entry requirements from development
An essential skill at entry is one without which a person cannot carry out their first assignments safely. Put other skills in the onboarding plan. Test the profile with an employee or an actual case and update it whenever the process changes, including between hiring rounds.
Profile of a fictional research coordinator
This is a fictional training example. The names, circumstances and outcomes are included solely to explain the method.
The coordinator gathers the initial request, arranges participation and makes sure findings can be traced back to the interviews. They select the research method with the lead researcher.
The role keeps the process organised and makes the materials traceable. The coordinator shares the decision about the research method, so the profile should state who is involved in agreeing it.
Requiring “experience with all research methods” would go beyond the work described. At entry, managing participants, materials and status updates matters most. Deeper knowledge of research methods can be developed on the job. The role and example are fictional.
| Element | Wording | Checks |
|---|---|---|
| Outcome | Materials are accessible and traceable | Owner and status are recorded |
| Decision | Chooses the order of communication | Within the project’s rules |
| Joint decision | Selects the method with the researcher | The partner’s role is named |
| Development | Learns new methods | Can be learned on the job |
Role profile template
Describe the work first, then formulate the requirements for candidates.
Role name and profile version: Purpose of the role: Key outcomes and who needs them: Typical tasks: Difficult situations: Independent decisions: Decisions that require approval: Key working relationships: Criteria for a good outcome: Essential at entry: Skills that can be learned: Risks and constraints: Sources and reviewers:
Check whether the profile works in practice
- The purpose and outcomes are clear without internal slogans.
- Independent decisions and joint decisions are clearly distinguished.
- Entry requirements relate to the first assignments.
- Disagreements between interviewees are resolved or clearly flagged.
A closer look
How is a role profile different from a job posting?
A profile is an internal description of a role, including outcomes and decision authority. A job posting adapts part of that information for candidates and the hiring process.
Should the profile list tools?
Only if the tools are genuinely required or substantially shape the work. It is often more useful to describe the task and its constraints and cover the specific tool during onboarding.