Stay interviews: how to find out what helps an employee stay and grow
How to hold a stay interview with a current employee: create a safe setting, discuss what works and what is difficult, agree on a feasible action and check the result.
The value of the conversation depends on what happens next
A broad question like “Are you happy with everything?” often gets a broad answer. An employee may find it easier to describe a recent moment when work went particularly well or a situation that drained their energy. These examples reveal working conditions such as clear priorities, access to a decision-maker, the speed of feedback or how work is distributed.
The conversation comes with no guarantee that the company can meet every request. The interviewer should be clear about what they can change themselves, what needs approval and what is out of reach for now. If someone fears repercussions for speaking frankly, a polished list of questions alone will do little to build trust.
Discuss the experience and end with a specific agreement
Explain the purpose and the boundaries
Explain that the conversation is about working conditions and development. Make clear that it won't be used as a covert assessment. Say how you will use the notes and which topics the employee can skip. If you plan to record the conversation, agree on this in advance and follow your organisation’s retention rules.
Start with recent events
Ask when, in the past few weeks, the employee felt their work was making a difference and when they ran into an unnecessary obstacle. Ask about the task, who was involved and what happened as a result. Hear the employee out and check that you understood the example and their expectations before responding.
Distinguish requests from underlying needs
“I want fewer meetings” could mean a need for time to tackle a complex task, for a clear agenda or for permission to decline an optional call. Ask follow-up questions to find out what the person means. Keep their account faithful to what they said, even if it is uncomfortable for the manager.
Choose an action and follow up
Agree on a small change, who's responsible and when you will review it. If other people need to sign off, say when you will seek their approval. If something is out of reach, explain why and avoid implying that it will happen. In the next meeting, ask whether the specific experience has changed, as well as how the employee feels.
A fictional conversation about repeated approvals
This is a fictional training example. The names, circumstances and outcomes are included solely to explain the method.
I enjoy tackling difficult cases, but it wears me out when I have to explain the same decision to different people in three meetings.
This identifies both a positive factor, the challenging cases, and a barrier, the repeated approvals. Before cancelling any meetings, check whether they have different owners and purposes.
One testable action would be to log repeated decisions for two weeks and try using one short decision record for everyone concerned. The employee and manager can then compare how many times the same decisions came up. This example is entirely fictional.
| Signal | Follow-up question | Possible action |
|---|---|---|
| “Too many meetings” | What exactly is repeated? | One decision record |
| “No development” | What experience do you need? | A trial assignment with support |
| “Too little clarity” | Where does the priority change? | A rule for recording decisions |
| “Everything’s fine” | When did work go especially well? | Keep the conditions that work |
Stay interview guide and action agreement
Record only what is needed. Keep promises, limits and matters requiring approval in separate fields.
Purpose and ground rules: What the employee wants to keep about the job: A recent positive experience: A recent obstacle: What the employee expected: What the manager can influence: What requires approval: One feasible action: Owner and deadline: How we will know things have improved: Follow-up date:
Check that the conversation leads somewhere
- The employee understood the purpose and how the notes would be used.
- The discussion included at least one specific example alongside general assessments.
- The agreed action is within reach of those responsible.
- Both sides have a date for reviewing the outcome.
A closer look
How often should you hold stay interviews?
It depends on the team, how quickly things change and the other ways people give feedback. Following through matters more than establishing a frequency. Stay interviews complement day-to-day management.
Does HR have to conduct the interview?
The line manager is often a good choice if there is trust and they have the authority to act. Sensitive topics may require another safe channel.